Skip to content

Share

Milkrun and the risks of growing with unprofitable orders

Performance improvement2023Updated 4 minute read
A delivery rider pulling away from a grocery dark store on an inner-city street

Milkrun’s original grocery-delivery business closed in 2023 after a period of rapid expansion. Its reported losses illustrate why a retailer needs to understand the contribution from an order and the cost of serving different customers before funding growth.

The Pricing Success Formula

The Pricing Success Formula cover

How to trace margin leakage from discounts, freight and the cost of serving individual customers.

We’ll email you a link to the PDF.

Read the report online
Contents and resources

The original Milkrun business

Funding and closure figures reported by ABC News in April 2023. Woolworths subsequently acquired the brand.

$86m
raised from investors
400
roles made redundant at closure
April 2023
the original business closed

Milkrun offered rapid grocery delivery from local warehouses. ABC News reported that the business had raised $86m before closing in April 2023, making all 400 roles redundant. The closure followed a period of tighter funding conditions.

In May 2023, Woolworths announced that it had acquired the Milkrun brand and would use it for its existing Metro60 service, with orders fulfilled from Metro stores. This article concerns the original business and the commercial questions its expansion raised.

Growth and delivery costs

June 2022 reporting identified a $13 loss per order at one Milkrun location, based on March trading.

For management, the question is which costs an additional order creates and how much income it brings. Sales growth can improve the use of a warehouse or delivery network, but the business needs a credible explanation of when that improvement will cover its costs.

Order contribution and customer profitability

An order’s contribution is the income left after the product and fulfilment costs attributable to that order. Customer profitability also depends on repeat purchasing, acquisition costs and ongoing support. A loss averaged across a location or period cannot establish the profitability of every customer or segment.

Start with basket revenue after discounts and refunds, less the cost of the goods. Add any delivery income, then deduct the picking, packing, payment and delivery costs. Compare the contribution across basket sizes, delivery areas and customer groups. Shared warehouse and head-office costs still need to be covered before the business earns a profit.

What to test before funding more orders

An illustrative assessment for a delivery business. These are analytical questions, not additional findings about Milkrun.

Basket size
What to measureProduct margin after discounts, compared with the cost of picking and packing the order.
Decision it informsWhether a minimum order value would improve contribution without losing too much demand.
Delivery area
What to measureDelivery income and cost by area, time window and route density.
Decision it informsWhere to offer the service and whether charges or delivery windows need to change.
Repeat purchasing
What to measureContribution from repeat orders, less acquisition and ongoing support costs.
Decision it informsWhether retaining or acquiring each customer group earns a return over time.

Zenith analysis applying the customer-profitability and cost-to-serve principles in The Pricing Success Formula.

What a pricing or delivery change must achieve

More volume can reduce average costs if it makes delivery routes denser or spreads shared costs across more orders. Where the income from additional orders remains below the extra cost of fulfilling them, however, expansion increases the losses. The investment case needs to show which operating assumptions would change and how management will test them.

A higher minimum order value may increase basket margin. A delivery charge may recover more of the cost to serve. Wider delivery windows or a different fulfilment model may reduce the cost of each trip. Each change also affects the customer’s reason to use the service, so the forecast needs to allow for customers buying less often or choosing an alternative.

Test a proposed change with a defined customer group and compare order frequency, contribution and service quality with the existing offer. Include the investment and cash needed before the expected savings arrive. An attractive eventual margin is insufficient if the business cannot fund the transition.

Use customer evidence to test the next investment

The practical lesson is to establish how growth would improve the economics before committing more capital. The Pricing Success Formula recommends reviewing profitability by customer segment and examining individual accounts where the cost to serve is high. It also explains how delivery charges and other pricing terms can change customer behaviour and margins.

For a broader expansion decision, The Four-Week Strategic Review shows how to compare market opportunities, operating requirements and financial scenarios. Together, these analyses help management decide which growth to fund and which assumptions need further testing.

Sources and further detail

Which orders and customers earn a return?

A pricing strategy session can help identify where delivery charges, discounts or the cost to serve are reducing margin, and which changes to test with customers.

Discuss pricing and customer profitability