Skip to content

Share

Bapcor and the perils of outsourcing your strategic transformation

Strategy implementation3 minute read
A trade counter in an automotive parts store

Bapcor’s “Better Than Before” strategic transformation was unwieldy and, according to one co-founder, left the business “Worse Than Before”.

Implementing Strategy

Implementing Strategy cover

How to build an initiative plan and see which decisions need the steering group’s attention.

We’ll email you a link to the PDF.

Read the report online
Contents and resources

“Better Than Before”, by the numbers.

Set against the ambition it was launched on, here is what the first twelve months actually returned.

$100m
Minimum net EBIT benefit Bapcor targeted for FY25
300
Separate projects running across the program
3
Profit downgrades in twelve months
27%
Share price decline over the same period

“Worse than before”

Bapcor set out its “Better Than Before” program at its November 2022 investor day. Its goal was an improvement of at least $100m in earnings before interest and tax from the program in FY25.

As reported in the Financial Review, the strategy involved a large team of McKinsey consultants working across 300 separate projects to deliver benefits.

Instead, the program left the business “Worse Than Before”, according to one of its co-founders, with three profit downgrades and a 27% share price decline in 12 months.

The business also faced internal disarray, with the unexpected withdrawal of the intended replacement CEO, and the impending retirement of the Board chair.

No wonder financial sponsors are circling the business.

Bapcor investor presentation slide outlining the Better Than Before transformation program
Bapcor’s “Better Than Before” investor presentation.

So what went wrong?

Bapcor is undoubtedly facing tougher market conditions than it did when its shares peaked during Covid.

At that time, the combination of large stimulus cheques and restrictions on personal freedoms would have benefited the automotive after-market sector, along with the DIY and home fitness sectors, among others.

But since then, rising interest rates have squeezed households and SMEs, with predictable results for those same sectors of the economy that benefited the most during Covid.

Bapcor’s problems seem to go beyond market-driven forces. The business has lost ground to key competitors SuperCheap Auto and Repco.

The combination of an unsettled leadership team and an unwieldy strategic transformation program appears to have contributed to an excessively inwardly-focused business that took its eye off the market.

It is too easy to get lost in the complexity of the transformation and lose touch with the market, all while drawing comfort from the fact that so much work is getting done on a weekly basis.

Secrets of effective strategic transformation

Bapcor may also have gone too far in outsourcing its strategic transformation to strategy consultants. A transformation program of 300 projects just sounds too complex and unwieldy for most businesses to take on, without, of course, the support of an army of consultants to provide the analytical horsepower.

But I would argue that a better approach is to be far more targeted, and to start with a much smaller set of strategic initiatives that make a material difference to the result.

Management needs to understand which customers and activities account for profit, and how changes in demand or competition could affect them.

And this process should be led by the management team rather than outsourced to consultants. This helps to build the buy-in and alignment among the management team that is critical for successful execution.

Outsourced

300 projects and an army of consultants

The complexity of the program becomes the work in itself, and a business drawing comfort from the volume of activity can lose touch with the market while it does so.

Management-led

A small set of initiatives with a material effect on the result

Management leads each initiative and tests the expected financial return against the capital and people available.

Our senior consultants develop the plan with management. Financial modelling tests the expected return from the proposed changes and whether the business has the capital and people to deliver them.

The result is a focused plan with a more manageable number of initiatives that allows for rapid execution and delivery of benefits.

You can learn more about our approach to strategy execution alongside.

Which initiatives need management’s attention?

If a program has too many competing projects, a principal can help you assess which ones underpin the strategy and where a decision or a change of owner is overdue.

Discuss strategy implementation